Earlier we fixed that when going into printable mode the URL parameters were lost and the topic was rendered useless, where it relied on such parameters for dynamic content.

Other such scenarios have been identified at TWiki:Codev.URLParamPersistence:

1. From a topic with dynamic content, go to "View Raw" mode, and then click "View Topic" at the bottom action bar. The topic is now rendered without the original URL parameters.

We need to

• collect any other such scenarios and
• decide whether these are defects or not.

For example, with respect to raw mode, one could argue that (i) the raw mode shows the text of the topic unrendered and therefore should ignore any URL parameters and (ii) going to view topic renders the topic literally shown in raw mode and should therefore not depend on any URL parameters but show the topic in its pure rendered form.

Having a more exhaustive list of such issues will allow us to make a consistent decision. -- TW